Thursday, October 11, 2007

Top 100

There’s a popular mystery writer called, notice I didn’t say named, John Sanford. His actual name is John Camp. He’s written a few books under his real name; but, mostly he makes his living writing “…Prey” novels starring Lucas Davenport in Minnesota. They're pretty good reads.

Lucas is married to Weather something or other, a physician. A few books back she gave him an Ipod or an MP3 player and a certificate to download a hundred songs.

He didn’t run out, so to speak, and get them. Nope.

Interspersed in the novel between his search for the maniacal killer, he ruminated about what he should download and talked to his fictional friends about it. He decided to download the best hundred rock songs of all time.

When the book ended, there were a couple of pages of titles. Some I agree with, others, not so much.

Back then, I talked to Big Rick (do a search on the blog if you are new and don’t know who I’m talking about) about compiling our list, inviting our friends to play. He immediately dismissed the idea, saying that there was no way he could narrow down the best hundred ever in his opinion; and, he certainly wasn’t going to argue with me about my picks (no Beatles, per Rick).

Then today at the local establishment, Rick said he’d gotten a link from the Drudge Report to Rolling Stone’s list of the best rock songs and albums of all time. He was shocked, outraged and pretty much pissed off at their picks. He went on for sometime. A pause. “And can you believe there was nothing by …?”

My idea of the best hundred would probably make a good meme. I’m expanding the category beyond rock. Classical, Country, Hip Hop, Gospel. You name it. What moves you? You want to nominate an album and not just a song, be my guest. List your favorites, post them at your place if you have a blog with a link to here if you are so inclined, leave them here in a comment, do both. Invite others to do the same if you want to. OK, I just invented a meme (non-blog people, it's a kind of chain letter with no reward, just like the real chain letters; though I've heard that Bill Gates and Warren Buffett are thinking of throwing a few million from the new foundation into the reality series, "Where are the Top 100 Now" that I'm producing on VH-1). Play if you want with whatever rules you want to follow.

List as few or as many as you want. Tell us why they’re the best, or not.

If there’s any kind of response, I’ll compile them down the road.

Here’s a few to start the process:

I’m So Lonesome I Could Cry. Hank Williams. One of the prettiest, saddest, most haunting songs I’ve ever heard.

Layla, all versions. By God. Nothing more need be said.

Mr. Bojangles. Sammy Davis, Jr. Best seen and heard in an early sixties black and white TV performance I saw as a kid on a show I don’t remember.

Stairway to Heaven. Led Zeppelin.

Days of Future Past. Moody Blues. Am I giving away my age?

Stardust. Willie Nelson.

Enough. Maybe I’ll add some later. Dr. Sardonicus, I do expect you, of all people, to play.

13 comments:

fermicat said...

Great idea, and it will be fun to see what people come up with. I'm going to go away and think about it for a while.

Anonymous said...

I'm in! I'll email you the list:-)

Debo Blue

Jeni said...

Damn! Sometimes Dave, you come up with such great ideas but then I realize my brain isn't equipped for some of these things - like this music thing! I love the idea! I'd play along too except for one small problem - I can never remember names of songs (or rarely) and hardly ever remember who the heck the artists were. What a dilemma!

I may have to go dig out some of my "classic" albums from their storage spaces -wherever that might be! (Translated - I have no clue where in the dickens I have them scattered about right now!)

Anonymous said...

I'll limit myself to three:

Will it go 'round in circles? by Billy Preston; Gentle On My Mind by Johnny Hartford; The Winner by Bobby Bare

Posol'stvo the Medved said...

See, now this is the kind of meme I can get behind. No tagging. Requires a bit of thinking, organization of thought, etc etc.

I like it.

100 is a lot, but that's part of what makes it fun.

The Curmudgeon said...

An impossible task, I think.

But I'll give you a couple of ultimate rock 'n' roll songs:

Lady Madonna by the Beatles
Travelin' Band by Credence Clearwater

Born to Wander -- Rare Earth
Ball of Confusion -- The Temptations

Now... going back... way back....

September Song -- by Walter Huston (father of John, grandfather of Anjelica)

Or how about a bunch from Louis Jordan: Is You Is (Or Is You Ain't) My Baby? -- What's the Use of Gettin' Sober (If You're Gonna Get Drunk Again)? -- Open the Door, Richard (I think the biggest recording of this song came from the Count Basie band -- and, while we're on the subject -- how about April in Paris?)

Can you do a Top 100 List without one from the Chairman of the Board? How about "That's Life"?

Steve Goodman wrote the Ultimate Country Song -- but consideration must be given to Tennessee Ernie Ford's "16 Tons." My Hank Williams nominee would be "You're Cheatin' Heart."

This could go on forever.

dr sardonicus said...

Hoo boy.

My long-term blogging goal is to write a little something - from a paragraph to an entire post - about every stinkin' one of the 1000+ titles in my album collection. Of course, at my pace, that project is likely to take years, and there's a danger of all of us drawing Social Security before I get around to my top 100.

I can think of maybe twenty to thirty off the top of my head; after that it gets tough. That's part of the reason for my album project - helping me sort out my feelings about the music I've listened to for the past 40-odd years. I'll post some titles on my blog this weekend, although much of the justification for them will have to come in their own sweet time.

Dave said...

I'm holding all of you to your promises. Thomas and Curmudgeon having fulfilled the assignment are excused.

As to their picks.

Billy Preston was one of the unsung greats of the Sixties and Seventies. Thanks Thomas for reminding me of him.

Curmudgeon, Ball of Confusion is a great pick. When I did my initial picks, I was trying to come up with something from Motown. My problem was that Motown, Seeger, The MC5 and Grand Funk Railroad were the local soundtrack to my young life. I couldn't narrow it down to a song or two.

I saw the original Supremes live at the Michigan State Fair and the original Temptations at the Detroit Auto Show.

I was also going to add a Sinatra song, That's Life is a good choice.

So if I had to pick one Elvis, what would it be? To me the songs weren't the important part, it was the voice.

Classical? Pictures on Exhibition. Night on Bald Mountain.

Classical American, if there is such a category? Rhapsody in Blue.

Scott Joplin. Muddy Waters. Nat King Cole. B.B. King. Can't choose among their stuff.

Anonymous said...

"Paint It Black" by the Stones is probably my all time fave rock song. "Lonesome Onr'y and Mean" by Waylon Jennings for Country. The One Who Got Away" by Tom Waits
for whatever kind of Music Tom Waits does. Opera, Leontyne Price:
"O Mio Babbino Caro". Favorite Oldie "Unchained Melody" by just about every artist who has ever recorded it. From Al Hibbler to the Rightious Brothers to David Allan Coe. It's just a beautiful song. "Fur Elise" by Beethoven andVivaldi's complete "Four Seasons" I find very pleasing to the ear.Sorry to drone on but out of almost 6000 songs on my mp3 player (Creative Labs Nomad Zen Jukebox)Its hard to pick just a few from the varied selection at hand.

Dave said...

Thanks for playing Rick, Mac says he's going to post some songs. I think I agree that Paint It Black is up there. For quintissential Stone though, maybe Satisfaction.

As you know I'm not much for opera, I doubt I'll give your choices a try. I know I like Tom Waits, but I can't name a song.

I was about to list Unchained Melody in my comment and then didn't, I'm suprised given your animous to the Beatles that you chose it. I'm not sure how I explain that opinion other than to say that it's more Beatles than Stones.

For the fifth or sixth time, you've got to, got to load the hard drive of the player on to the computer. If it ever crashes, you have a new six month process, pleasurable for awhile, but....

Keith said...

So Dave says I'm the only metal guy. I'll do my best.

Black Sabbath-Iron Man
Metallica-Enter Sandman
AC/DC-Highway to Hell
Iron Maiden-The Number of the Beast
Motorhead-Ace of Spades
Megadeath-Peace Sells

And for when I used to smoke the wacky tabacco? I would have to say Pink Floyd-Comfortably Numb.

There is a story behind that. My best friend and I bought the album The Wall by Pink Floyd the day it came out. We went out and got some good smoke and listened to it over and over and over again. Ahhhh...the good old days. I think the year was 1979. But things were hazy back then. Ha!

Dave said...

Thanks Keith. And you whipped that right out.

Now, plain old rock and roll, I know you were listening.

Anonymous said...

Hi Dave,
Here's 4 off the top of my head for your list:
1) Piano Man - Billy Joel
2) Back in Black - AC/DC
3) Friends in Low Places - Garth Brooks
4) No Sugar Tonight - Guess Who Vidoe here: (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iy75uEPaXeE)